← Back to all signals

AEO AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC

Last updated: Mar 16, 2026

Execution Consistency

Did the company actually spend money buying back stock in 3+ of the last 4 quarters?

Bought back stock in 2/4 quarters. Q3 2024: $0M, Q3 2025: $0M, Q2 2024: $96M, Q2 2025: $96M

🐻

Execution Acceleration

Is the most recent quarter's buyback spend more than 15% above the trailing average?

Latest quarter $0M vs trailing avg $64M (-100%)

Buyback vs FCF

What percentage of free cash flow is going to buybacks? Bull: 30-80%. Bear: <10% or >80%.

Negative FCF ($-329M), cannot compute buyback ratio

Buyback Intensity

How fast are they shrinking the float? Bull: 2%+ annually. Bear: under 0.5%.

Missing shares repurchased or outstanding data

🐻

Insider Buying

Are officers and directors buying stock with their own money on the open market?

No insider open-market purchases in the last 12 months

Insider-Buyback Convergence

Are insider purchases happening during the same quarters the company is actively buying back stock?

Need both buyback and insider purchase data

🐻

Insider Net Direction

Looking at all open-market transactions, are insiders net buyers or net sellers?

Insiders bought $0M, sold $64M (net selling)

🚩

Red Flag

Active buyback + insiders net selling 3x+ more than buying. Company cash may be supporting price while insiders exit.

Company buying back stock while insiders sold 64112010.5x more than bought. 3 C-suite officers among sellers

  • SCHOTTENSTEIN JAY L (Exec Chairman & CEO) sold 500,000 shares on 2026-01-20
  • SCHOTTENSTEIN JAY L (Exec Chairman & CEO) sold 527,343 shares on 2026-01-21
  • SCHOTTENSTEIN JAY L (Exec Chairman & CEO) sold 21,236 shares on 2026-01-22
  • Mathias Michael A. (EVP and CFO) sold 186,580 shares on 2025-12-05
  • Foyle Jennifer M. (Global Brand President-aerie) sold 243,047 shares on 2025-12-05
  • Mathias Michael A. (EVP and CFO) sold 40,471 shares on 2025-09-16
  • Foyle Jennifer M. (Global Brand President-aerie) sold 54,950 shares on 2025-09-08
  • Foyle Jennifer M. (Global Brand President-aerie) sold 30,000 shares on 2024-10-01
  • SCHOTTENSTEIN JAY L (Exec Chairman & CEO) sold 598,356 shares on 2024-09-19
  • SCHOTTENSTEIN JAY L (Exec Chairman & CEO) sold 401,643 shares on 2024-09-19